By M.P. Pellicer | Stranger Than Fiction Stories
On December 10, 1909, Eliza Gribble and her daughter Carrie Ohlander were discovered beaten to death inside their home located at 401 West Perry Street, Savannah, Georgia. Not too far from them Maggie Hunter was found clinging to life, she was also beaten and her throat was slit. She died three days later at the hospital.
The Gribble House stood on the outskirts of Savannah in an unsavory neighborhood known as Frogtow, which was close to the railroad yard, saloons and other seedy businesses.
A widow renting out rooms in a rundown boarding house, occupied by two divorcees, fit right into the dubious reputation that the townspeople had for those who lived in this part of Savannah.
The reason this figures in the story, is the area housed many undesirables, including thieves, drug addicts and unsavory characters, any of who could have committed the crime.
Later its location close to the railroad track figured into the theory the killer was a railroad worker, who committed the deed and then left the area.
Carrie Ohlander, who was partially deaf had been raped, and afterwards her throat had been slit. She had recently separated from her husband who stayed living in Memphis. Her mother, Eliza Gribble, 70, immigrated from Cornwall during the American Civil War. She was found in a back bedroom with her skull bashed in. Next to her on the floor were her spectacles and newspapers she'd been reading.
Maggie Hunter, 34, rented a room at the Gribble House. She moved in the day prior to the attack and had recently separated from her third husband J. C. Hunter her was 30 years her senior. She planned to make a living as a seamstress.
Hunter’s real name was David L. Taylor. He served in the 63rd Regiment Georgia Volunteer Infantry during the Civil War. Afterwards he turned to crime and went to jail twice, once for stealing a horse, and the second time for bigamy. After his last stretch in jail, he changed his name to Hunter. He was missing an eye, and walked with a cane.
The murder weapon was a bloody ax found at the scene; however this choice was not that unusual as most households of that time had one, either for chopping wood, killing a chicken, etc. The murder of Lizzie Borden’s parents in 1892, was carried out with a similar weapon.
When the story made the headlines, a riot broke out in the city as mobs went on a witch hunt looking for the murderer. The gruesome story made the headlines around the country.
Bloodhounds were brought in and the city mayor offered a $1000 reward for the capture of the perpetrator.
Margaret Elizabeth "Maggie" Wise Hunter, who was barely alive at the hospital, revealed to Rev. John S. Wilder, a Baptist minister who was sitting at her bedside, that the killer was her husband J. C. Hunter. Police were immediately notified, and arrested Mr. Hunter. Inside the home they found bloody clothing stuffed inside the fireplace.
Maggie later died and was interred at Laurel Grove Cemetery as was Eliza and Carrie.
On February 23, 1910, the Chatham County grand jury indicted J. C. Hunter, Willie Walls and John Coker for the triple murders. All three men denied any involvement, and on August 17, 1910, Hunter was convicted and sentenced to death by hanging. He appealed his sentence and he was slated to hang on December 22, 1911. The same Rev. Wilder who heard his wife’s accusation against him, baptized Hunter the day before his execution date. Hunter escaped hanging when the governor commuted his sentence to life in prison. On October 27, 1923, he was pardoned by Governor Clifford Walker. He then returned to Savannah.
J. C. Hunter was a painter and paper hanger originally from Guyton, Georgia. Not only was the age difference odd between Maggie and Hunter, but the fact that he often referred to her as his daughter, and she in return called him the “old man”.
Willie Walls, one of the other men suspected of the murder, said he came to see Maggie on the same day of the attack. It was found that he paid Maggie’s rent at the Gribble House for an entire month. He was only questioned, but never went to trial since the case against him was so weak. It was believed he was Maggie’s lover.
The other accused was Bingham Bryan, who at the time of the murders was the yardman for the property. It was believed his motive was robbery, as there was a rumor circulating that Mrs. Gribble had an old trunk full of wills, stocks and other valuables. Even though he was held, there was no evidence against him, and he was released.
John Coker whose arrest was based on information provided by a neighbor, was released after it was found the servant who gave testimony was a cocaine addict, and was hoping to gain some type of reward money from the story.
THEORIES ABOUT THE MURDER
At the time there was more than one theory surrounding this murder, especially as to who were the intended victims. The crime scene indicated the first two victims were Eliza and her daughter Carrie. This theory was confirmed when family and friends of Maggie Hunter told police she breakfasted with her sister, Mrs. Hewlett. She later stopped at three nearby houses, trying to sell some remnants of cloth to get money. Another witness claimed they saw Maggie Hunter walking towards Perry Street, and she appeared to be drunk. Based on this timeline, she probably arrived as the murders were taking place.
This was not the only mystery surrounding this crime, when six days afterward another witness came forward saying that Maggie Hunter had predicted her own death.
On December 16, 1909, the Morning News reported that Maggie had stated: “the bloody work would be done”. The witness was John Flatman, an insurance salesman who on the day of the crime met with Mrs. Hunter at her sister’s house early that day in order to collect a premium.
She didn’t have the money, and he told her if she made payment by Saturday, the insurance policy would be intact. She replied by saying she did not think she would be alive on that date. Mr. Flatman asked her if she planned to kill herself, and she said no, and that he would be surprised by how later in the day the bloody work would be done. Mr. Flatman said Maggie Hunter was sober, but very nervous when she spoke to him. The affidavit provided to the police by this witness made them think this was not a random act of violence.
There was also speculation as to why no one heard anything from the home as the killer attacked the victims, especially as the murders were believed to have taken place around 2 p.m. This coincided with the lunch time of various people who worked very close to the location of the house.
Another twist in the tale came from another witness, who said that J.C. Hunter threatened to kill his wife before. Police also learned Hunter had papered the inside of the Gribble home six years before, and was familiar with the interior.
In March, 1917, while J.C. Hunter was still serving his sentence for the murder, a man named J.B. Gaving approached a Savannah policeman serving in the National Guard at the Mexico border during the hunt for Pancho Villa. He claimed responsibility for the murder of the women. He said he committed the crime with a partner, and described the interior of the house with great detail. He was considered insane and his confession was discounted.
THE GHOST STORIES
The Gribble house was demolished in 1941, and by 1944, another building was erected on the site which later became the Old Town Trolley Tours, where stories continue to persist of paranormal occurrences in the part of the building where the house once stood.
In 1974, the Morning News interviewed Elizabeth White Monsees who grew up in the area of the Gribble House before WWI. She said ghost stories about the house on Elbert Square described where blood stains would appear mysteriously on the walls. The house continued to be used as a boarding house, even after the murders and different guests reported on these phenomena.
Employees working in the building where the Gribble House used to stand complained of different paranormal encounters. One person described a huge, black mass came out from between two parked trolley cars.
Could these be the restless spirits of the three women, stuck in an eternal hell where the crime is recreated, or the ghost of J.C. Hunter who is seeking forgiveness for what he did? Or maybe the ghost is that of a diabolical killer who never paid for his crime, and comes back to revisit the scene of the murder. In this version there is no trolley barn, but the Gribble House intact and standing as it once did, with three women that became the victims of his blood lust.
The Ghost Adventures team completed an investigation on May 17, 2014.
Stranger Than Fiction Stories by M.P. Pellicer